Children develop prejudice at an early age
Children in the Netherlands develop prejudices based on ethnicity at an early age. Ymke de Bruijn (27) came to this conclusion in her dissertation ‘Child Interethnic Prejudice in the Netherlands: Social Learning from Parents and Picture Books’. For her PhD project she took a closer look at the behaviours and ideologies young children are exposed to by their parents and through picture books between the ages of six and ten. De Bruin will defend her thesis on 11 January.
De Bruijn took time to speak to us while on holiday to tell us more about her PhD research, which is part of a larger research project run by Leiden University College (LUC) under the supervision of Professor Judi Mesman: ‘KidS: Kinderen in de Samenleving’ (Children in Society). How do children perceive diversity in society? Which prejudice do they have against people from various ethnic backgrounds? De Bruijn: ‘I have a background in behavioural sciences and I think it’s very interesting and important to look at the way in which children develop prejudice and how that’s addressed. My research shows that it’s not true that children do not distinguish between people from various ethnical backgrounds.’
Nip prejudice in the bud
According to De Bruijn it is important to nip the development of prejudice in the bud at the earliest possible stage. This is what motivated her research. ‘Hardly any research has been done on this in the Netherlands, whereas it has in other countries. I wanted to gain an understanding of how prejudice manifests itself in children in the Netherlands. What do their parents or picture books teach them on this subject and how does that contribute – in both a positive and a negative sense – to possible prejudice?’
Recruitment massive undertaking
The research project started in 2017. Finding parents and children willing to participate was a massive undertaking. Parents and children were recruited through social media and at children’s events, markets and indoor playgrounds. In the end, almost 300 children and their parents were visited at home and asked questions in interviews, games and computer assignmen. De Bruin: ‘Before coronavirus we visited people at home, but then we had to do everything digitally. That was different from expected and took some getting used to for us and for the children and their parents.'
‘When we phrased these questions negatively, the white children were selected less often than the other children. The results show that white children in the Netherlands develop certain preferences at a young age.’
Who would you like to invite to your birthday?
The children were shown pictures of children of different ethnicities: white children, black children, and children with a Middle Eastern appearance. White children most often selected the white children in the pictures in response to positively formulated questions such as: Who would you like to play with, who would you like to invite to your birthday and who would you like to sit next to? ‘When we phrased these questions negatively, the white children were selected less often than the other children. The results show that white children in the Netherlands develop certain preferences at a young age,’ De Bruin explains.
Colour blindness has counterproductive effect
De Bruin looked at various diversity ideologies and found that children whose parents lean strongly towards a multicultural ideology were less prejudiced, whereas a ‘colour-blind’ ideology did not have a positive effect. Multiple conclusions on the influence of parents can be drawn here. ‘Simply not discussing it, “colour-blind parenting” has a counterproductive effect and isn’t a very good idea. The child’ll start to feel uncomfortable if you don’t talk it, because they do notice the differences and may come to see them as scary or negative.’ According to De Bruijn, parents should be encouraged to discuss ethnicity and racism with their children.
Greater awareness needed from publishers and users of books
De Bruijn concludes that it continues to be important for children’s book publishers to pay attention to diversity. ‘It seems that diversity in books won’t automatically happen overnight. Publishers shouldn’t only think: how often does a character of colour appear in my book, but also: how are these characters portrayed?’ For users of books, De Bruijn advises becoming more aware of the choices you make as, for example, a parent or teacher. ‘If you’re not actively paying attention to it, chances are that you’re not offering enough diversity.’
Follow-up research required
De Bruijn hopes that follow-up research will provide practical tips for parents on how to start conversations on ethnicity with their children. ‘We’ve taken an important first step with this research, but for some parents it’s still very difficult to put this into practice. What should or shouldn’t they say and what is the resulting effect? That would be a good next step’, says De Bruijn, who once she has received her PhD will become a postdoc researcher on Mesman’s team .
De Bruijn sees Tuesday’s defence as the final step in her PhD journey. ‘I think that after Tuesday I’ll finally have feel as though I’m really done. Unfortunately, there won’t be an audience present. I really would have liked to celebrate this moment together with others, to raise a glass to all the hard work.’
Follow the livestream here on Tuesday.
Text: Margriet van der Zee
Research project ‘KidS’: Kinderen in de Samenleving
This research project led by Judi Mesman is about how children view diversity in society. There are several PhD tracks in this research. De Bruijn is the first of the group to receive a PhD. Daudi van Veen, Fadime Pektas and Yiran Yang are the other PhD students. There is also a postdoc working on the project: Rosanneke Emmen.